“Then came the unexpected twist. The Schmidts eventually challenged Herman’s ownership of approximately 80 acres.”
Imagine renting your neighbor’s pasture, then deciding you might own it. Awkward.
For the families around Pelican Lake, changing water levels eventually raised a question no one could ignore: who owned the land left behind? That question became a very real dispute for two families in Wright County, Minnesota, more than 80 years ago.
Back in the late 1800s, Herman Marschel’s family used part of the land along the lake as pasture. His father had fenced in a portion of it, and Herman continued maintaining the property after taking over the farm. As Pelican Lake’s water levels changed, areas of exposed lakebed stretched between the water and the surrounding properties. Herman treated the soon to be disputed ground as his own for decades. He cleared trees, removed rocks, planted clover, and allowed others to use the pasture. He even rented the pasture to his neighbors, the Schmidts.
Then came the unexpected twist. The Schmidts eventually challenged Herman’s ownership of approximately 80 acres. The very neighbors who had rented his pasture were now disputing who owned the land beneath their feet. The disagreement made its way to the Minnesota Supreme Court, which ruled in Herman’s favor in 1942. The court found that his long-standing, open use of the property had established ownership under a legal principle called adverse possession. In everyday terms, he had treated the land as his own for so long, and so openly, that the law recognized his ownership.
And the Marschel family’s connection to Pelican Lake have continued through the generations. Rodger Marschel and his wife, Karen, are still living and working along the lake. Their farm includes a 100-acre native prairie field bordering the water, and they support efforts with Ducks Unlimited and the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources to improve the lake’s habitat for ducks and other wildlife. Including a major lake restoration project completed in 2018, helping bring Pelican Lake back toward its historic role as an important destination for waterfowl.
It’s quite a change in perspective across the generations. Herman’s chapter involved a fence, a pasture, and an 80-acre ownership dispute. The later Marschels became part of the effort to protect the lake and the wildlife that depends on it. And for anyone researching property along a changing shoreline, Pelican Lake offers a reminder that the history behind a property line can be anything but ordinary. At Real Title Services, we know that sometimes the most interesting details are the ones hidden in the records.

0 Comments